Reputation Management Services: All-In-One Guide

Your online reputation is like a resume for your business, listing off your expertise and acting as a way for customers to discern if you are up to snuff. It influences what potential customers think about you and can significantly impact whether they will do business with you. 

This guide is here to help local business owners, like yourself, navigate the world of reputation management services and find the right provider for you. We’ll keep it simple and practical, focusing on what matters most for your growth.

Automatically request reviews to amplify your online reputation

The Significance of Online Reputation

Imagine you’re the captain of a ship. Your online reputation is the wind guiding your sails. Reputation management services are like your navigational tools, helping you control the direction of the wind. These services are designed to shape how people perceive your business online.

Whether it’s asking for positive reviews, responding to customer feedback, or dealing with any rough waters, reputation management services are what you need to expertly steer through the good, the bad, and the ugly. 

Tip: How to Ask for a Review: Best Practices and Templates

Why Your Local Business Needs a Good Online Rep

In your local community, a strong reputation can prove more fruitful than the best marketing campaign. People trust businesses with a solid reputation. When potential customers search for services like yours, they often rely on the reviews of others to find the best place to do business. In fact, a positive online reputation can be the deciding factor for them to choose you over a competitor. It’s like having a word-of-mouth recommendation—but online!

When Do You Need Reputation Management Services?

You might be thinking, “I’m a small business; do I really need this?” The answer is yes, and here’s why. Reputation management involves a lot—tracking what people say about you, managing online reviews, and making sure your business looks good across the internet. 

Handling all of this on your own can be like trying to balance a swaying pile of never-ending tasks. Reputation management services can take some of those responsibilities off your shoulders, letting you focus on what you do best—running your business.

Benefits of Reputation Management Services

Let’s talk about the good stuff. Reputation management services aren’t just a fancy “good-to-have”; they’re an investment in your growth. Here’s how:

1. Building Credibility and Trust

Think of it like building a trustworthy relationship with your patrons. Positive reviews and a good online presence instill confidence in potential customers and convince them to buy.

Effective reputation management strategies also help local businesses lessen the impact of bad press. That means you shouldn’t panic if you receive a poor review every once in a while. People are more inclined to trust a business with a higher ratio of good feedback left for them. 

Think about it, would you decide not to buy your dream couch if it had 1000 positive reviews and 5 negative ones? In all likelihood, the negative reviews were a one-off and are not going to impact your experience with the product.

2. Enhanced Visibility and Brand Image

Improving how easily people find you online is an important part of reputation management. Maintaining accurate listing information and a strong public image helps your business show up higher in Google search results when people are looking for services like yours.

However, it is important to note that it’s not just Google you need to appeal to. You need to keep your image consistent and positive across as many influential online platforms as possible, so customers get a clear and trustworthy impression of your brand wherever they encounter it, whether that be on social media posts or on their mobile invoice.

Consider your industry, and think about where your customers are most likely to leave a review. If you’re a restaurant, you should check out Yelp or Facebook, and if you are a home services business, a great place to start is Angi (formerly Angie’s List).

3. Improving Customer Relationships

You can improve your relationship with your customers by implementing a solid reputation management plan. By encouraging positive interactions, addressing concerns, and showing that you care, reputation management services help you build the bonds that keep your customers coming back.

4. Crisis Management

Dealing with tough situations online is part of the job. Reputation management steps in to help businesses navigate and recover from such crises. Crisis management involves anticipating likely threats and developing strategies to cope with their impact. 

In this section, let’s look at some real-world examples we gathered from Smartsheet where businesses effectively managed and recovered from challenging situations, showcasing successful tactics and lessons learned in the process:

CPG Product Crisis Management Example: Tylenol Product Tampering

In 1982, Tylenol faced a crisis when seven people in Chicago died after consuming capsules tainted with cyanide. The tampering occurred when someone injected the chemical into capsules and returned them to the store. The way Johnson & Johnson handled the crisis became a renowned case study for effective crisis management.

Key Points in Tylenol’s Crisis Management

Fast and Decisive Action: Upon the first two deaths, the company took swift action by halting all product advertising, sending 450,000 messages to stakeholders, and establishing toll-free hotlines for consumers. Despite the hefty cost exceeding $100 million, Johnson & Johnson initiated one of the first nationwide recalls, recalling all products from store shelves, even when government officials deemed it excessive. The company also issued warnings to consumers not to take its pain reliever.

Honesty and Integrity: Johnson & Johnson demonstrated honesty by not evading blame, despite evidence that the poison was introduced via store shelves. CEO James Burke’s transparent approach earned the company praise. Tylenol pioneered tamper-proof packaging and shifted from capsules to a more tamper-resistant caplet.

Despite the crisis, Tylenol managed to regain its market share and sales leadership within a year. According to a BrandSpark study, Tylenol continues to rank highly for consumer trust, showcasing the enduring impact of effective crisis management.

While some companies triumph, others give way under pressure. Here are five of the most expensive corporate crises that were not managed as well as Tylenol, and the lessons we should take away from them:

reputation management services

(Source, Smartsheet)

How Reputation Management Services Work

Okay, let’s get into the nitty-gritty of how these services function.

1. Monitoring Online Presence

Imagine having eyes everywhere, always looking out for your business. Reputation management tools track what people are saying about you and alert you in real time.

2. Creating Positive Content

Have you ever read a really great article about a business that left a big impression on you? That’s the power of positive content. Reputation management services help you create engaging content that overshadows any bad press. 

SEO strategies are used to help push this good news higher in search results and place negative news out of sight and out of mind.

3. Review Management

Reputation management services guide you in responding to negative reviews and provide ways to encourage satisfied customers to leave positive ones.

4. Social Media Management

Social media is like a digital bulletin board. Reputation management keeps your board positive, engaging with customers, and handling any negativity.

5. Crisis Response

Imagine having a plan for when things go wrong. Reputation management services help you respond to crises, whether it’s issuing statements or managing your brand image on social media.

6. Competitor Monitoring

Ever wanted to know what your competitors were up to? Reputation management keeps an eye on them, helping you find opportunities to shine.

Choosing the Right Reputation Management Service

Finding the best reputation management service platform can be tricky. Not all tools are created equal, and many cater to specific industries, business sizes, and budgets.

Together, let’s look past all the jargon and identify the steps to finding the right reputation management service provider for your business.

1. Consider Your Needs

What do you need the most help with? Write down the problems you are currently facing and rank them in order of importance to help you find your biggest pain points. This can help you determine your most pressing needs and your “nice-to-haves.”

2. Ask Questions

Don’t be shy. Ask potential service providers questions about how they can help your business specifically. You don’t need a sales pitch—you need facts. So, don’t be afraid to ask for spec sheets, brochures, and other product materials to help you make the best-informed decision.

3. Learn from Others

Case studies are like success stories. However, what works for a hair salon might not work for a painting business. Look for reputation management services that have helped businesses just like yours succeed. If case studies are not available, search public forums, review sites, and other resources to gauge how businesses found working with the provider.

Tip: Top 10 Reputation Management Tools

Challenges in Reputation Management

Reputation management is not all smooth sailing, and we want to be honest about it. Here are some things you might face while trying to manage your public image.

1. Dealing with Fake Reviews

Sometimes, people and competitors play dirty. Reputation management helps you navigate these tactics and ways to remove fake reviews from public view.

2. Balancing Transparency

In many ways, transparency is like walking a tightrope. Reputation management helps you balance being transparent while also respecting customer privacy.

3. Tackling Negative SEO Tactics

Everyone is desperately trying to get ahead, and in competition, not everyone decides to play fair. Reputation management services help you tackle these tactics head-on and clear your name.

In conclusion: your reputation matters, and it is never too late to start managing it. Investing in reputation management services is like giving your business the confidence boost it deserves. It’s not just about dealing with issues; it’s about actively shaping how people see your local business online today and in the future.

How Broadly Helps With Online Reputation for Small Businesses

Broadly is your reputation management ally. Our user-friendly platform is designed for local businesses like yours, helping you take control of your online reputation. Curious to learn more? Schedule a demo with us today.

Watch your online reputation transform with Broadly